Our Ice Cream Menu

To play, press and hold the enter key. To stop, release the enter key.

Welcome to South Street Creamery's handcrafted ice cream experience! Every flavor is made in-house using natural, high-quality ingredients, delivering that nostalgic charm with every scoop. From beloved classics to bold, limited-edition creations, there’s something here for every sweet tooth.

Same Day Cakes

Homemade at our shop and ready for last-minute pickups, this ice cream cake comes in either

vanilla & chocolate or Oreo cookies & cream (other flavors upon request)

6” Ice Cream Cake $29.00
8” Ice Cream Cake $35.00

Custom Cakes

Please provide at least two days' advance notice.

6” Ice Cream Cake $34.00
8” Ice Cream Cake $40.00
10” Ice Cream Cake $53.00
12” Ice Cream Cake $62.00
Sheet Ice Cream Cake $89.00

Ice Cream Pints

Classic Flavors $9.99

Indulge in timeless favorites that have been delighting our guests for over two decades:

Butter Pecan – Buttery base with real pecan pieces
Cherry Vanilla – Real vanilla and swirls of cherry
Chocolate – Made with 100% real Dutch cocoa
Chocolate Chip Fudge – Rich chocolate chunks and fudge swirled through vanilla
Coffee – Real coffee means real caffeine
Cookie Dough – A classic for a reason
Cookies & Cream – An Oreo crowd-favorite!
Grandma’s Kitchen – Vanilla with cake batter, chocolate frosting, and cookie dough pieces
Jockey Hollow – Vanilla malt base layered with peanut butter & chocolate-covered pretzels
Kahlua Madness – Kahlua-coffee base with fudge and chocolate espresso beans
Mint Chocolate Chip – Perfect for after dinner or a mid-day treat
Purple Cow Tracks – Black raspberry base with fudge and chocolate chunk pieces
Sweet Cream – The base for all of our ice creams
Strawberry – Made always with (pounds and pounds of) real strawberries
Vanilla – Made with Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla

Limited Edition Flavors $9.99

Seasonal favorites and small-batch specials you won’t want to miss:

Baileys Irish Cream – Boozy Baileys base with caramel ribbons
Brown Cow PB Oreo – Light chocolate with peanut butter and Oreos
Cake Butter – A buttery-batter base the whole family will love
Caramel Cinnadoodle – Cinnamon ice cream with caramel swirls
Chocolate Cookie Monster – Chocolate base with cookie dough, Oreos & chocolate chips
Coconut – Light, refreshing, and perfect for summer
Cookie Butter – Rich cookie butter base—simple but irresistible
Cotton Candy – A boardwalk-inspired, kid-favorite treat
Dulce de Leche – Rich caramel base with caramel swirls
Great Swamp – Coffee base with graham crackers & chocolate-covered almonds
Mint Fudge Brownie – Mint base with swirls of fudge and brownie bits

Sugar-Free Flavors $9.99

Sweet satisfaction without the sugar:

Chocolate Cherry – Chocolate base with cherry pieces throughout
Chocolate Churro – Cinnamon chocolate base with caramel and chocolate chips
Vanilla Fudge – A sugar-free take on a classic combo

Soft Serves $9.99

Creamy, dreamy swirls to brighten your day:

Chocolate Soft Serve – A rich and satisfying swirl
Vanilla Soft Serve – Smooth, creamy, and classic
Vanilla & Chocolate Twist – A perfect duo of two favorites

Dairy-Free Flavors $9.99

Full of flavor, free of dairy—scoops everyone can enjoy.

Strawberries & Cream – A dreamy twist of Dole Whip and Custard
Strawberry Dole Whip – Our vegan staff favorite
Vanilla Custard – An eggy, rich summer delight

Our Flavored Ice Menu $9.99

Cool, refreshing, and full of flavor—our Italian-style ices are the perfect treat for hot days, after-school cravings, or anytime you need a fruity, frozen pick-me-up. Each one is made with vibrant ingredients and served with a swirl of joy.

Blue Raspberry Ice – A crowd favorite, and easily our most popular ice
Cherry Ice – Deep red with a burst of flavor, perfect with Lemon or on its own
Lemon Ice – A sharp citrus bite, refreshing for any weather
Orange Ice – A blood orange base sure to satisfy any dessert need
Peach Ice – The perfect ice needed to help jump-start your day
Strawberry Ice – Made with real strawberries—try our newest (and definitely creamiest) Italian ice
Watermelon Ice – Refreshingly pink and tasty to boot!

Novelties

From sundaes to splits, these classics bring the fun (and the fudge) to every scoop.

Affogato – An Italian dessert consisting of a shot of espresso poured over a one scoop of vanilla ice cream! $8.25
Banana Split – For the true ice cream lover, our banana split comes with three scoops and three toppings packed between a split banana and all topped with hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry! $10.25
Quart of Ice Cream – Stock up on your favorite flavors for holidays and special occasions! Or plan ahead to save those rare and seasonal ice creams before they disappear $16.95
Saturdae – The one-scoop version of our classic sundae, the Saturdae comes with hot fudge, whipped cream, a cherry, and 1 topping of your choice $7.95
Sundae – Our classic sundae combo, featuring two scoops of your favorite two flavors with hot fudge and 2 toppings of your choice! Topped with whipped cream and a cherry $8.95
Weekdae – The junior version of our classic sundae, the Weekdae features a kid’s scoop of your favorite flavor with hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry $6.95