Welcome to the South Street Creamery Cafe Since 1999, home to Morristown’s own award winning homemade ice cream made fresh daily by our family to yours. We use pure vanilla, real Dutch chocolate, fresh fruits, lots of candies, nuts and other natural flavors to produce daily the freshest, creamiest and richest ice cream you’ll find. Our family’s commitment is to craft wholesome food that you will feel good sharing with your family and friends. That is why we insist on hand selecting the finest produce and meats which we carefully season and roast in our Creamery kitchens. Our motto is "Always fresh. Always homemade."

Only at the South Street Creamery Café will you find our much acclaimed café menu. Nothing fried. No preservatives. Just simply delicious. You can enjoy our homemade soups, sweet or savory French crepes, hearty sandwiches, inspired paninis and fresh salads complimented with our very own dressings.

South Street Creamery nj

At the South Street Creamery Café we feature a variety of gourmet treats to satisfy everyone:

  • Ice Cream Cakes
  • Gourmet Coffees and Italian Espresso
  • Catering and Make-Your-Own-Sundae Parties at your location
  • Homemade Award Winning Ice Cream and rich Italian Gelato
  • Fresh baked goods and variety of fudge like no other
  • Non fat Yogurt and Sugar Free Ice Creams
  • Home of Peter's SloBaked Granola
  • Handpacked Pints & Quarts

We love our community and our loyal customers, that’s why we have made it easier than ever to order directly from South Street Creamery. Order directly through our brand new website or download our mobile app (available on iOS & Android). Make sure our mobile app is on your phone and keep an eye out for special deals and promotions!

Download on App Store Download on Google Play Store

What People Are Saying view all

  • ”I have been coming here since I was a kid! I love love love this place. Both sides of the cafe are amazing. The sandwich are fresh and healthy. The ice cream and gelatos are soooo good, there is no bad flavor!" -Eriny M.
  • ” Best ice cream ever. Ben & Jerrys and Haagen Dazs lost my business to the Creamery. " –Marianne K.

Ice Cream Flavors

*Vanilla - National Award Winning. Made with pure Madagascar Bourbon
*Mint Chip
*Jockey Hollow - Vanilla Malt Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Covered Pretzels
*Butter Pecan
*Sweet Cream
*Cookie Dough
*Grandma's Kitchen - Vanilla Ice Cream wtih Cake Batter, Cookie Dough and Chocolate Fudge Icing
*Cotton Candy
*Black Raspberry
*Great Swamp - Coffee base, and chocolate covered peanuts
*Chocolate Chip
*Persian Ice Cream - Rosewater, Pistachio, and Saffron
*Pumpkin Pie
*Cherry Vanilla
*Candy Cane
*Brown Cow PB Oreo - Chocolate Vanilla Base, with peanut butter and oreos
*Apple Pie
*Chocolate PB Cookie Dough

Currently Available Flavors
Flavors May Contain Nuts, no flavor is 100% sure to be nut free